Keith’s in Whiting: A True Hidden Gem for Steak and Good Company
There’s something special about finding a restaurant that doesn’t rely on hype or trends to earn its reputation. Keith’s in Whiting is one of those places. It’s one of the most underrated steakhouses in the Region, and the more time you spend there, the more you realize why locals are loyal to it.
Keith’s has been part of the Whiting community since 1990. It’s located right in the heart of downtown at 1872 Indianapolis Boulevard. From the outside, Keith’s looks simple and unassuming. But the moment you walk inside, it feels warm, cozy, and full of character. You’ll notice unique touches like the mermaid sculpture and vintage artwork, and you can tell right away that it’s a place built on personality rather than trends.
The layout of the restaurant creates a relaxed atmosphere. There’s a bar area near the front where Keith himself is often greeting customers and serving drinks. The main dining room has an inviting and comfortable feel, where you can enjoy conversation without needing to raise your voice. Toward the back, there’s a more private section that works well for larger groups and special occasions.
The service at Keith’s is something people talk about. The staff is friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. They make sure drinks stay filled and are always willing to explain a dish or make a recommendation. There’s a genuine sense of hospitality that makes the whole experience feel personal and unrushed.
The service at Keith’s is something people talk about. The staff is friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. They make sure drinks stay filled and are always willing to explain a dish or make a recommendation. There’s a genuine sense of hospitality that makes the whole experience feel personal and unrushed.
The menu is full of high-quality options including steak, seafood, pasta, salads, soups, and more. Portions are generous, so it’s not uncommon to leave with leftovers for the next day. The steaks are a standout and well worth the price, but if you’re not in the mood for steak, the house burger is a great option and an excellent value. Every entrée includes soup or salad, mashed potatoes, and green beans, which makes the meal feel complete and satisfying.
Because Keith’s is only open select hours and is well-loved by locals, reservations are typically recommended. The restaurant is usually open Friday and Saturday from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m., and you can reach them by phone or message them through their Facebook page to secure a table.
Whiting has always been a tight-knit, character-rich community. It’s the kind of place where local businesses matter and where supporting those businesses truly keeps the heart of the town beating. Keith’s is a perfect example of that. It’s a comfortable, welcoming restaurant that serves great food without trying to be something it’s not.
If you haven’t been to Keith’s yet, consider this your reminder to plan a night out and try it. And if you already know and love Keith’s, then you know exactly what makes it special.
Keith’s Bar and Grill
1872 Indianapolis Blvd.
Whiting, Indiana
Phone: 219-659-4444
